WHETHER YOU are a die-hard ice cream fan or just in the mood for a sweet treat, Mister Goodies is a must-visit gem in Lynchburg. This ice cream shop has become a staple for locals, and each scoop is a testament to the shop’s commitment to quality. As you wait in line amidst the outdoor seating, the sweet aroma of waffle cones and chocolate syrup envelops you, promising a delightful treat. The friendly staff is always ready with a smile, which makes the experience even more enjoyable.
The menu at Mister Goodies includes everything but the kitchen sink. From frozen cheesecake on a stick to hot apple dumplings, soft serve, and soda floats, this shop has whatever you are craving. I chose the Strawberry Fudge Basket — soft serve vanilla ice cream in a waffle bowl, topped with strawberries and hot fudge. The ice cream was perfectly sweet without being overwhelmingly rich, and the strawberry and hot fudge combination added a fresh and light element that was necessary to finish the large portion.
Popular favorites include the Flavorburst and rotating flavor cones, the rotating dairy-free and vegan flavors, and the Mister Goodies banana split. Currently, Mister Goodies offers eight dairy-free/vegan flavors, including cake batter, peanut butter, and coffee Oreo.
The charm of this shop is largely due to the outdoor seating. There is a playful energy, with dogs and kids running around and ice cream everywhere you look. Each table holds a variety of desserts, and the joy is almost palpable. Mister Goodies offers more than incredible desserts — it offers a child-like experience that contributes joy and escape to the Lynchburg community. Good News tested, Good News approved! GN