IF YOU’RE searching for one of Bowling Green’s top dining spots, Gerard’s 1907 Tavern is unbeatable. This restaurant stands out with exceptional service, a stunning historic building, and mouthwatering cuisine. Situated next to the charming Fountain Square Park, Gerard’s offers a curated selection of craft beers, artisanal cocktails, and a menu that expertly blends tradition with innovation.
The restaurant exudes coziness, featuring plush velvet chairs, inviting banquette seating, and a bar area for those seeking a more casual dining experience. Our server, Savanah, was exceptional — attentive and knowledgeable, always ready to answer our questions about the menu and nightly specials. She graciously catered to our requests, including our indulgence in multiple bread baskets, perfectly paired with a starter of gooey goat cheese fondue, served with an assortment of crudites, apples, and delectable homemade croutons. The cocktail menu is extensive, and I enjoyed a seasonal cocktail made with fresh blackberries, vodka, and honey.
The dinner menu offers a selection of classic dishes like basil pesto chicken, seared salmon, and an outstanding beef stroganoff made with tender beef tips, onions, and a rich Dijon cream sauce. Savanah mentioned that the stroganoff is served with mashed potatoes instead of the traditional noodles, a twist that some diners might initially hesitate to try. However, I can assure you that those diners are missing out — this substitution takes the dish to a whole new level. She also noted that for those who try it this way, it often becomes their go-to order. I can vouch for this, as I’m already planning my return just to enjoy it again.
Burgers are another highlight at Gerard’s, with various tempting options like the Fig & Brie Burger and the signature GT Burger, featuring Henry Bain sauce, smoked Gouda, house coleslaw, and crispy tobacco onions. If you’re ordering ketchup for your house-made fries, be sure to request their in-house version. It includes a secret ingredient (which I won’t reveal here) that transforms this classic condiment into something truly crave-worthy.
We indulged in a classic creme brulee for dessert, which lived up to all our expectations. I’m already looking forward to my next visit to Gerard’s for another delightful meal. GN