GOOD NEWS IS COMING TO DINNER! We will feature a local food critic’s thoughts as they dine in Manchester. This month, Shannon Beebe visited Italia’s Orange Blossom Pizzeria.
ITALIA’S ORANGE Blossom Pizzeria is a welcome new addition to Winchester, and after my first visit, it’s easy to see why it’s already making an impression. Located just outside of downtown, this spot brings an authentic taste of New York–style pizza to our area — and does it with confidence.

We started with a beautifully presented charcuterie-style appetizer that set the tone for the meal. Fresh grapes, olives, creamy cheese drizzled with balsamic, thin-sliced cured meats, warm bread, and crisp crackers made for a shareable, well-balanced start. It felt thoughtful and elevated, in the best way.

Their pizza, though, is the star. A thin, foldable crust with a light char, well-seasoned sauce, and generous toppings immediately signals authentic New York-style pizza. One slice pull revealed the perfect cheese stretch that pizza lovers chase, and the balance between sauce, cheese, and toppings was spot on. Each bite was flavorful without being heavy, and the crust held up exactly as it should.
You can also tell care is being taken behind the counter. The open kitchen and visible oven add to the experience, and the friendly, welcoming atmosphere makes it feel like a place you’ll want to return to — not just grab and go once.

Overall, Italia’s Orange Blossom Pizzeria feels like a strong start for a new restaurant in Winchester. Great food, inviting presentation, and authentic flavors make it worth the visit. If you’ve been craving authentic New York–style pizza close to home, this new spot just outside downtown deserves a place on your must-try list. GN
Italia’s Orange Blossom Pizzeria:
401 Lynchburg Rd.
Winchester, TN 37398
Shannon Beebe: franklincountyfoodcritic@gmail.com




























































































































































































































